Hi,

I'm having difficulty removing the left side cup and lockring on my mid 80's stumpjumper. It won't move when I wrench it. I used penetrating oil, but it is stuck. What should I do to get it to loosen up and remove it?

Jeff

What have you tried at this point? You should use a hooked spanner to remove the lockring, like the upper tool in this picture:


Once the lockring is off, you can use a pin spanner to remove the cup:


Bike shops often have more effective (and expensive) tools they can bring to bear if you can't do the job with the tools you have at home.

Single hook is most often insufficient, i.e. sufficient for destroying the lockring but insufficient for moving it. Few grab points are preferred. Otherwise, to remove the cup, you need secure the BB tool with a bolt+washer screwed into the axle of BB, to keep the tool in place.

Sometimes it takes more than gentle force to pop off an old lockring. This is the tool of choice used by old timers who do lots of these. If you don't want to buy or borrow one, consider letting the LBS do this job, or simply set an old dull chisel into one of the notches and giving it a sharp hammer blow. Don't tap it, that just drives the chisel in, give it a meaningful shot which should sent it spinning off.

Once the lock ring is off you can try the cup, but if it's rusted in there's a good chance that it'll shear the pins off a two pin tool. There were 6-pin tools back in the day for stubborn cups, but i don't know if they can be had today. If 2-pins isn't enough, and you have a small home shop, you can make a 6-pin tool yourself from scrap metal, or resort to desperate measures. Try driving the cup out with a chisel or punch set into a hole, or try grabbing the cup with a big pair of Channellocks, or try clamping the cup in a vise and turning the frame.

If it's really seized, you might try getting the right side off first (Don't forget that many are left hand threaded) then using a fine thread 9/16" bole and nut to work the left off.

If I am not reusing a lockring I remove it with a pipe wrench. Make sure you are turning the right way.

Ok, thanks for the great advice. I actually ordered the park tools necessary for the job.

Now the stupid question, which way do I turn it off? Right or left?

Jeff

That's easy, left is always right. It's right that's tricky; left for British, and right for French and Italian.

To clarify, It's a RH thread so you turn it counter-clockwise to loosen.

Adjustable cups are always standard thread, so counterclockwise will loosen it.